If your 2027 health insurance renewal increase just landed and the number made you wince, you’re in good company. In a September 2026 eHealth survey of 500+ owners and managers at firms with up to 500 employees, 54% reported double-digit premium increases for 2027, and more than one in five said 15% or higher. About 80% said the increase was bigger than they expected.
The good news: a renewal letter is an opening offer, not a final answer. Most small employers have more room to move than they think, and the window between now and open enrollment is when those moves are cheapest. Here are five to work through.
1. Find out what’s driving your health insurance renewal increase
Before you react to the percentage, ask your broker or carrier what is driving it. A renewal is typically some mix of medical trend, your group’s own claims experience, age and demographic changes, and carrier rating adjustments. If the increase is mostly trend, your leverage is in plan design and shopping. If it is mostly your own claims, the conversation is different. Either way, you want to know which one before you decide what to do.
2. Shop your small group health plan
Carriers price small groups differently, and the gap between the highest and lowest quote for the same group can be large. Ask your broker to take your census to market, including carriers you haven’t used. Start early: quoting, underwriting, and employee communication all take longer than owners expect, and the closer you get to your renewal date the fewer options remain.
3. Adjust plan design before shifting costs to employees
Shifting cost to employees through higher premiums is the blunt tool. Often there are gentler ones. Consider raising deductibles or out-of-pocket maximums on one plan option, adding a narrower-network or higher-deductible HSA-eligible plan alongside your current one, or revisiting copay structures. Offering a lower-cost option next to your current plan lets employees trade down voluntarily instead of having a cost increase imposed on them.
4. Price a level-funded health plan against your renewal
Interest in level-funded and self-funded arrangements is rising among small employers, according to the same eHealth survey. In a level-funded plan you pay a fixed monthly amount that covers expected claims, administration, and stop-loss insurance. If claims come in lower than expected, you may get part of the difference back; if claims run high, stop-loss limits your exposure. It is not right for every group, and healthier, stable groups tend to benefit most, so ask for a side-by-side quote against your fully-insured renewal and read the stop-loss terms closely.
5. Set your employer contribution strategy on purpose
How much you contribute, and to which tiers (employee-only versus dependents), is a budget lever and a recruiting message at the same time. Run the numbers on a few scenarios: holding your employee-only contribution steady while adjusting dependent contributions, moving to a fixed-dollar contribution so your cost is predictable, or splitting the increase with employees. Before you finalize anything, confirm your employee-only contribution still meets the IRS affordability threshold if you are an applicable large employer (50 or more full-time equivalents).
Open enrollment timeline: put dates on the calendar
Work backward from your open enrollment start date. You will need final plan selections, carrier paperwork, and employee communication materials in hand well before it opens, and any plan change requires lead time with the carrier. If your renewal date is January 1, the decisions in this article should be made in the next few weeks, not in December.
The bottom line on a double-digit renewal
A double-digit renewal does not mean double-digit pain. Understand what is driving the number, make carriers compete, redesign before you cost-shift, test level-funding, and set contributions deliberately. If you’d like a second set of eyes on your renewal, Maxwell Agency can review it with you and take your group to market.
Frequently asked questions
How much can a small employer’s health insurance renewal increase?
Small group renewals vary by carrier, state, and your group’s claims experience. In an eHealth survey of owners and managers at firms with up to 500 employees (September 2026), 54% reported double-digit premium increases for 2027.
Can I negotiate a health insurance renewal?
Often, yes. Ask what is driving the increase, request alternative plan designs from your current carrier, and have your broker quote competing carriers before you accept.
What is a level-funded health plan?
A level-funded plan is a form of self-funding where you pay a fixed monthly amount covering expected claims, administration, and stop-loss insurance. Unused claim dollars may be returned, and stop-loss limits your exposure if claims run high.
When should I start planning for open enrollment?
Start 90 to 120 days before your renewal date so you have time to quote, decide, and communicate changes to employees.
Source: eHealth small and mid-sized business survey, released September 16, 2026.
