We thought open enrollment was going great
One of our longest-standing clients has been with us for well over a decade. Their workforce is largely Spanish-speaking, and they’re the kind of employer who genuinely cares whether their people get value out of their benefits.
For the past three to four years, we’ve run their open enrollment through online enrollment technology. Elections were clean. Paperwork was gone. Deadlines were hit.
By every measure we were tracking, it was working.
Then we listened a little closer, and realized we’d been measuring the wrong thing.
What we were doing
We didn’t just hand employees a login and walk away.
Every employee got a one-on-one virtual session with our team. We’d share our screen, walk through their benefit options, review their elections, and answer questions about deductibles, copays, and what plan made sense for their family.
On paper, that’s a high-touch process. Personal attention, real answers, and the efficiency of a digital platform.
Enrollments were fast. Errors were down. Everyone was enrolled on time.
What we were missing
Here’s the hard truth: the team still felt like they didn’t really understand their benefits.
They’d enrolled. They’d picked a plan. But when it came time to actually use it — a trip to urgent care, a prescription, a specialist referral — a lot of them weren’t confident about what they had or what it would cost.
Looking back, the reasons make sense:
- A screen share isn’t a conversation. People nod along on a video call even when they’re lost.
- The small questions never got asked. “Does this cover my kid’s glasses?” or “What happens if I go to the ER at night?” tend to come out when someone feels comfortable, not when they’re watching a cursor move around a screen.
- Language and comfort matter. For many employees, asking a follow-up question in a second language, on a call, felt like a burden. So they didn’t.
- We couldn’t read the room. In person, you see the hesitation before someone says “I’m fine.” Virtually, we missed it.
The process was efficient. It just wasn’t effective.
The pivot: same technology, back in the room
We didn’t throw out the online enrollment platform. It’s still the backbone of the process — it keeps elections accurate, carriers updated, and HR’s workload manageable.
What we changed is how employees experience it.
We’re now holding one-on-one, face-to-face enrollment interviews on site. Same platform, same elections, but now with someone sitting across the table who can:
- Explain the plan in plain language, in English or Spanish
- Use real examples from that employee’s life
- Catch the confused look and slow down
- Answer the one-off questions that never came up over video
It takes more of our time. That’s fine. The goal of open enrollment isn’t to finish fast — it’s for every employee to walk away knowing what they have and how to use it.
What this means for employers
Technology makes open enrollment easier. It doesn’t automatically make it better.
If you’re an employer, a few questions worth asking before your next renewal:
- Do your employees actually understand their deductibles, copays, and out-of-pocket max — or did they just click through?
- Is enrollment support available in the languages your team is most comfortable speaking?
- When was the last time someone asked your employees how open enrollment went for them?
You’re spending real money on benefits. They only pay off when your people know how to use them.
At Maxwell Agency, we help small and mid-sized employers across Los Angeles, Orange County, and the Inland Empire build an open enrollment process that fits their workforce — digital, face-to-face, or a blend of both.
If your team’s enrollment feels efficient but you’re not sure it’s landing, let’s talk. 🙂
